View Single Post
Old 08-30-2012, 12:15 AM   #1
Babbling Farker
Join Date: 05-04-08
Location: Boise, Idaho
Default Test Cook: Pit Barrel Cooker Baby Back Ribs

Test Cook: Pit Barrel Cooker Baby Back Ribs

I've had my Pit Barrel Cooker (PBC) for just under six months and it has
become my go-to cooker for most of my outdoor cooking -- especially
tri-tip and chicken. The thing is just so easy to use and the food it
produces is simply outstanding. I decided to see how good of a rib cooker
it is, and the results honestly blew me away.

Not only is the PBC an outstanding backyard cooker, but I've used them
twice in as my sole cooker in competition, including helping the Pit Barrel
Cooker Company team beat the venerable Johnny "Godfather of Ribs" Trigg
in both ribs and pork at a recent competition at Craig, Colorado. That is a
huge testimony to the versatility and results that you get from this cooker.

For competition I always use a fairly complex process for my ribs that
entails cooking them "bare" (just seasoned with rub) indirectly in smoke for
a while, then I wrap them in foil with a liquid for a while. I then unwrap and
sauce them, and I cook them directly over the coals for a few minutes to
"set" the sauce (so that the sauce caramelizes a little and get sticky). This
is a very common method for cooking competition ribs, but it's admittedly a
huge hassle.

What follows are my precise results from a recent test cook where I
explored how the PBC would deal with a no-nonsense rib cook that is as
close to set-it-and-forget-it as I could make it.

  • 2 Racks (2.73 lbs each) "enhanced" loin back ribs (same thickness
    and length)
  • Seasoned heavily with a 50/50 blend of Pit Barrel All-Purpose and
    Beef & Game Pit rubs
    (about 1 Tbsp of each per rack)
  • Let sit, seasoned, at room temperature for 20 minutes while the
    coals started
  • 2 Chicken halves (5.08 lbs total) for cooker load ballast
  • Full basket of Kingsford Original (from a fresh unopened bag). Doused
    the coals with lighter fluid (about a cup), lit and waited 20 minutes.
  • No wood chips, chunks or pellets were used.
  • 86º / No wind / No rain / Cooker in the shade
  • 7:20 - Lit the coals
  • 7:40 - Hung one rack of ribs and one chicken half on each rod with
    the bones of each facing the inside barrel wall (about 2 1/2" from the
  • 9:40 - Removed the chicken (it was done)
  • 11:10 - Ribs done and removed (perfect probe test between the
  • Total cook time: 3 1/2 hours
  • Average temperature: 290º
  • The ribs were never foiled, basted or spritzed.
  • The ribs had excellent color, were juicy, and had perfect
  • The thin ribs at the end above the basket were crispy, but not
  • The ribs were salty, as I would expect with store-bought
    "enhanced" ribs. I'd recommend using un-enhanced ribs and just
    a moderate coat of rub.

As I said earlier, the results simply blew me away. I hit them with a light
coat of sauce after they came off and they were some serious
competition-grade ribs. I'd happily serve these to a judge any day! The
brain-dead-easy simplicity makes me kick myself for jumping through hoops
for all these years.

PatioDaddio is offline   Reply With Quote

Thanks from:--->