The BBQ BRETHREN FORUMS.

The BBQ BRETHREN FORUMS. (http://www.bbq-brethren.com/forum/index.php)
-   Q-talk (http://www.bbq-brethren.com/forum/forumdisplay.php?f=5)
-   -   New Brinkman Offset design for 2014? (http://www.bbq-brethren.com/forum/showthread.php?t=185979)

SkinnyVinny 04-10-2014 03:07 PM

New Brinkman Offset design for 2014?
 
Hi All,

Noticed this bad boy online from a local hardware store. Just says offset smoker, but Brinkmann is the company. Model #855-4305-F for those interested. $269 CDN is what it is selling for.

http://www.rona.ca/images/12685001_L.jpg

So what do you all think? Looks like they upgraded their old offset smoker and gave it more of a "Lang" feel without the Lang price :rolleyes:

Most likely will have the same quality as the previous brinkman, and most likely will require some mods as well. Only found one review so far that seems to confirm this.

Hopefully I have time this weekend to check it out in person if they have it on display and take some pics. Either way, I'll be waiting in the fall to see how far they'll be discounted before purchasing.

chunkylatinlover 04-10-2014 04:33 PM

For that price I would go with the Oklahoma Joe they sell at Walmart. Its the same price but bigger and more than likely thicker steel.
http://www.walmart.com/ip/Oklahoma-J...Black/33605961

revkab 04-10-2014 10:08 PM

The old Brinkman was made of 1/4" steel and worked wonderfully. This one is 1/8" or less and not made nearly as well. I bought the 1/4" one 5- years ago and it has been working wonderfully.

64Driver 04-10-2014 10:23 PM

1/4" on a Brinkmann? Which model? My 4 yr old one is the next grade up from tin foil. When I get my Shirley next week, it's gonna have a 3/8" CC and FB....a big step up!

Harbormaster 04-11-2014 12:26 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by 64Driver (Post 2879262)
1/4" on a Brinkmann? Which model?

The old Cimmaron models were 1/4" steel. Mine is 12 to 15 yo and it's 1/4".

64Driver 04-11-2014 07:29 AM

Thanks Harbor. I now know that Brinkmann has made some significant reductions in their product. Didn't know they had 1/4" ones before. Guess they wanted to go the thinner metal/cheaper price way. Whatever makes them money I guess...

ButtBurner 04-11-2014 07:44 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by 64Driver (Post 2879432)
Thanks Harbor. I now know that Brinkmann has made some significant reductions in their product. Didn't know they had 1/4" ones before. Guess they wanted to go the thinner metal/cheaper price way. Whatever makes them money I guess...

Brinkmann has been around a long time and has had many quailty products in the past.

The price of the materials dictates the selling price. Its impossible to make a 1/4" smoker these days and sell it for $269.

They produce cookers for the mass market, and have introduced many people to our hobby who would otherwise be priced out of it.

smokainmuskoka 04-11-2014 07:59 AM

SkinnyVinny - welcome!

I'm curious where you're located. I noticed the review indicated the writer was around Guelph, ON and got his at Rona.

My comment would be that mods or not, if you want to cook year 'round, that Brinkmann will not cooperate in the Canadian winter. I know some people drape a moving blanket around the cook chamber to help against wind-chill.

I bought a Char-Griller "American Gourmet" model from Canadian Tire about 9 years ago and got my best result on a blistering hot August day. I will admit I was a long way off from learning decent fire control though, and do plan to take another crack at the cooker this summer.

I've had much better product coming off my Weber 22.5" kettle and an Ugly Drum Smoker I built 2 years ago. I have minimal metal working skills - if I can build an UDS, almost anyone can. I cook on both all year in Muskoka and this year we had a frostier than usual winter. As long as there's a bit of a wind break, I do OK

What are you cooking on at present? A Weber kettle can make awesome 'Que, and I think you'd be tending it about as much as an offset. I also love my UDS and use it the most.

I do understand the old school attraction of an offset, though. I fell for it and plan to pursue more carefully this summer.

revkab 04-11-2014 10:34 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ButtBurner (Post 2879443)
Brinkmann has been around a long time and has had many quailty products in the past.

The price of the materials dictates the selling price. Its impossible to make a 1/4" smoker these days and sell it for $269.

They produce cookers for the mass market, and have introduced many people to our hobby who would otherwise be priced out of it.

The "Cimmaron" sounds about right. It is the one with the smaller iron wheels. The CC is 16" dia, I think, as is the FB. Everything, except the grates, etc is fully welded; the smokestack is also 1/4", but is held into a flange with a heavy duty bolt.

I bought mine at Westlake Ace Hardware 7-8 years ago for $500.00 and it was worth every cent. Although I have the big offset in my profile pic, this Brinkman is still fully functional and I still use it.

The one in the pic in this thread's original post is a nice unit, but not nearly as well done. It is somewhat better than the tinfoil designs that are similar elsewhere, but I think I'd spend that money on a better quality unit.

SkinnyVinny 04-11-2014 01:01 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by smokainmuskoka (Post 2879455)
SkinnyVinny - welcome!

I'm curious where you're located. I noticed the review indicated the writer was around Guelph, ON and got his at Rona.

My comment would be that mods or not, if you want to cook year 'round, that Brinkmann will not cooperate in the Canadian winter. I know some people drape a moving blanket around the cook chamber to help against wind-chill.

I bought a Char-Griller "American Gourmet" model from Canadian Tire about 9 years ago and got my best result on a blistering hot August day. I will admit I was a long way off from learning decent fire control though, and do plan to take another crack at the cooker this summer.

I've had much better product coming off my Weber 22.5" kettle and an Ugly Drum Smoker I built 2 years ago. I have minimal metal working skills - if I can build an UDS, almost anyone can. I cook on both all year in Muskoka and this year we had a frostier than usual winter. As long as there's a bit of a wind break, I do OK

What are you cooking on at present? A Weber kettle can make awesome 'Que, and I think you'd be tending it about as much as an offset. I also love my UDS and use it the most.

I do understand the old school attraction of an offset, though. I fell for it and plan to pursue more carefully this summer.


Hey smokainmuskoka! I'm probably west of you a little bit, located in the heart of the prairies!

currently have UDS, 22.5 weber, and the lil smokin joe. The UDS is awesome, but lately I've been going to the weber. Just love the versatility of the thing!

Kind of like the idea of having an offset. Nice little conversation piece. Was hoping with the newish design that it would be better than the older char griller version they sell at CDN tire. But I'm guessing this brinkmann will still have the same issues.

Either way, will be waiting til the fall to see what goes on clearance. Target cleared out the 22.5 webers for ~$50, so I might just get another one of those!

Friedturkeyspam 04-11-2014 01:16 PM

This looks similar and same price.

http://www.walmart.com/ip/Oklahoma-J...roduct+Reviews

smokainmuskoka 04-11-2014 01:24 PM

My Cdn Tire offset is an excellent storage bin, but I have promised myself to divine it's mysteries soon...

Good luck with your offset hunt!

oldbill 04-11-2014 01:31 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by chunkylatinlover (Post 2878901)
For that price I would go with the Oklahoma Joe they sell at Walmart. Its the same price but bigger and more than likely thicker steel.
http://www.walmart.com/ip/Oklahoma-J...Black/33605961

I was looking at the Oklahoma Joe at Wal-Mart just two days ago while waiting for an oil change to be done on my car and I'll have to say that it looked pretty good for a box store cooker! Good thick steel and well flanged around the lid!:thumb:

oldbill 04-11-2014 01:34 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by SkinnyVinny (Post 2878789)
Hi All,

Noticed this bad boy online from a local hardware store. Just says offset smoker, but Brinkmann is the company. Model #855-4305-F for those interested. $269 CDN is what it is selling for.

http://www.rona.ca/images/12685001_L.jpg

So what do you all think? Looks like they upgraded their old offset smoker and gave it more of a "Lang" feel without the Lang price :rolleyes:

Most likely will have the same quality as the previous brinkman, and most likely will require some mods as well. Only found one review so far that seems to confirm this.

Hopefully I have time this weekend to check it out in person if they have it on display and take some pics. Either way, I'll be waiting in the fall to see how far they'll be discounted before purchasing.

Nice looking little cooker, kinda reminds me of the old NB Hondo! Id be interested to see what the insides look like!:grin:

Grimm5577 04-11-2014 03:56 PM

looks like the cooking chamber is a lot shorter than the brinkman trailmaster I have. All in all my trailmaster has been a decent cooker for when i'm cooking a lot of food. definitely needed some mods to perform consistently.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 07:24 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.8
Copyright ©2000 - 2016, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.
2003 -2012 BBQ-Brethren Inc. All rights reserved. All Content and Flaming Pig Logo are registered and protected under U.S and International Copyright and Trademarks. Content Within this Website Is Property of BBQ Brethren Inc. Reproduction or alteration is strictly prohibited.