i've never had issues with temp on my UDS , i still get up to check it and its always been spot on , if outside temp is a big problem , wrap it with a welding blanket , that will help insulate it , welding blanket
02-17-2013 02:22 AM
02-17-2013 07:00 AM
All mine are made the k.i.s.s. method and I set them at nine at night get up around five thirty or six and it's still chugging along at the temp I went to bed at.I always wonder why ppl add these temp gizmos when a correctly made UDS should run perfect all night. This has been my experiences for a couple years now. I would save my $$ for meat. I've done many overnight shoulders,butts and briskets without a hiccup. And lose no sleep. I used to get up and check but no more.
02-17-2013 07:27 AM
Originally Posted by scottjess
What auto temp do you recommend in terms of price & ease of install for the UDS?
Its called practice. :rolleyes:
The UDS is as automatic as they come!
02-17-2013 09:47 AM
Originally Posted by scottjess
As much as I love my ballvalve; I would prefer something more 'set & forget'
So you have built a UDS with "issues" then.
I don't get it. What's more set it and forget it than a fridge magnet or a ball valve?
The problem is your UDS. When done properly and tweaked right they ARE set it and forget it. There are many of us that designed a UDS and had fire issues but we tweaked them out.... OR tweaked our fire management skills (which is more like how to load ONCE, what to use, and how to start).
So, you are not in the minority having a defective UDS. But if you look for air leaks, check your lid, and especially take mind of your lighting and charcoal fire management techniques you will have the same experiences most of us do.
Here is mine.... I start the coals (10-15 coals) on top of my other coals. I adjust my valves to where I usually experience 200 or 230 or 275 (depending on what I am wanting). Open the lid and plop the meat on. Quickly put the lid on and somewhere between 12-15 hours later I have to shake the drum to settle the ashes. Some with smaller baskets shake sooner then the temp goes right up.
The whole reason we build these things is for the set it and forget it concept. I NEVER need to smoke 12-15 hours but I can smoke up to 20+ with NO ADJUSTMENTS. My first time yes, it took a while to dial it in as I have TWO ball valves. But once you do your done if you remember.
Look, I have faith in you. I can think of 16 people I have seen as stupid as a brick dial their UDSs in and I have faith you can too. It just doesn't make since to spend $80 bucks making something that is perfection already but just needs a tweak here and there, only to buy 200-300 worth of apparatus to make it work like it could naturally. Not to mention, what if your blower fails.
Plus, UDS don't lend themselves to air exchange too well. IMHO. That's my opinion.
Granted, if this is the way you want to go.. there are people in here that can help with all the electronic stuff. There is nothing wrong with these people and the electronic blowers. I just think you can do it. And if you do, and you get your UDS tweaked right... jussst right, you will then realize that you are superior to those in every way. :-o
02-17-2013 10:10 AM
If you want to get a controller, i use the digiq dx2 and it works very well on my WSM. I bought the bbq guru stainless 3/4" ball valve adapter for my uds but i never use it.
With the uds I find it is more important to pay attention on how you load and light your charcoal. I have 3 - 3/4" pipe nipples on mine and basically run one wide open, one closed, and adjust temperature with the ball valve. Catch your temperatures on the way up and start closing down when you are 25-50 degrees from your target temp. I find that once I have the uds set, it chugs along within 5-10 degrees depending on how windy it is outside.
I would say try doing it manually - it won't cost you anything but a little of your time. Try to learn fire control - it is much easier than you think. If you are concerned with the what ifs in the middle of the night, buy a maverick 732 or igrill which have user programmable temp alarms and will alert you if your temps fall outside of your target range. If you find that you don't like doing it manually, then spend the money on a controller.
02-17-2013 12:05 PM
Okay thanks for the replies guys.
I will not buy a fan instead I will persevere with manual control. I can dial it in to a reno and it stays fairly constant for a good few hours so I guess next weekend I will cook a butt over night.