The BBQ BRETHREN FORUMS.

The BBQ BRETHREN FORUMS. (http://www.bbq-brethren.com/forum/index.php)
-   For the Board (http://www.bbq-brethren.com/forum/forumdisplay.php?f=51)
-   -   State Championship status (http://www.bbq-brethren.com/forum/showthread.php?t=130396)

roksmith 04-11-2012 11:24 AM

State Championship status
 
A thread was started in the competition area warning contest organizers to update their championship proclamations.
I'm concerned that, as an organizer, I had to read a message board to find out that our State Championship was no longer going to be honored by the American Royal, one of the two contests most organizers bother getting a proclamation for.
From the email I received from the Royal manager, it's not a change in their invite rules, but because of mis-information given out by KCBS that once a contest receives their proclamation, they are good to go forever.
The only real reason to obtain a State Championship proclamation is to be considered for an invite the the Royal and the Jack.
Now many contests listed as State Championships on the KCBS site will no longer be considered for an AR invite. I have not heard back from Jack Daniels yet to see if their policy is the same, but I believe a great dis-service has been done by the KCBS to it's membership and events.
Some sort of agreement should have been worked out to allow any contest the KCBS says is a State Championship to be grandfathered in for at least a year. Also some sort of message should have been communicated to sanctioned events to let them know their championship status is no longer valid.
An organizer should not have to watch a forum to find out their GC will no linger get an invite to the upper level championships.
I do realize that the KCBS does not control either the Royal or the Jack, but it certainly owes it's paying members and event something and negotiating with the events or at least notifying it's events of something like this is not beyond what would be expected from an organization.

Smoke Ring 04-11-2012 03:19 PM

KCBS used to track proclamations and send AR and Jack organizers a report listing all the qualifying contests and the GCs. They discontinued tracking the events, and sending the reports, putting the burden onto the AR and Jack, as well as the organizers of qualifying events who must now submit paperwork along with the winning team. Of course they never notified anyone they were making this change. There was a one line reference in the BOD minutes.

KCBS no longer serves its members. It has become little more than a shill for their corporate sponsors.

Ford 04-11-2012 03:19 PM

KCBS is one of many sanctioning bodies for the royal and jack. Some are taking a more proactive approach but it really should have been the 2 invitationals that tried to contact organizers. The real problem is with organizers that put a specific date including year in their proclamation. If it just says the contest name then it should be good forever. So date = problem created by organizers. The 7 day to send in paperwork change has nothing to do with sanctioning bodies.

It would have been nice for the KCBS to send an email to organizers telling them the invitationals were making a change. As I already said some sanctioning bodies are out front of this including telling winning teams and organizers about the one week rule as well as providing copies of a "valid" proclamation with the winners notification to the invitational.

Guess the invitationals thought it was getting too eBay to qualify.

drbbq 04-11-2012 03:51 PM

Let's not ignore the fact that KCBS was accepting expired proclamations from organizers. If they had made the organizers keep their procs up to date this problem wouldn't exist.

YankeeBBQ 04-11-2012 04:24 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by drbbq (Post 2011910)
Let's not ignore the fact that KCBS was accepting expired proclamations from organizers. If they had made the organizers keep their procs up to date this problem wouldn't exist.

Is it a fact that the Royal required a new proclamation every year ? If they did then why weren't they verifying that information every year ? Lay the facts on me Doc.

carlyle 04-11-2012 04:52 PM

I don't know if it is a Royal requirement, but our previous proclamations had a specific date on them when we received them from the Gov. office. So they were self limiting.

Now Minnesota has a blanket proclamation good for the rest of present governors term of office.

I am not that Dr. , but was presumptuous enough to interject my 2 cents worth anyway. :)

Jeff_in_KC 04-11-2012 05:40 PM

I've only seen 3 or 4 proclamations and none of them ever had an expiration date on them.

drbbq 04-11-2012 07:28 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by YankeeBBQ (Post 2011957)
Is it a fact that the Royal required a new proclamation every year ? If they did then why weren't they verifying that information every year ? Lay the facts on me Doc.

I don't think the point is "New" proclamation every year, but nice spin. The point as I know it is the dates. Some procs are forever and some are for a year. The ones for a year are only good for a year.

I can't speak for the Royal but common sense tells me the expired ones aren't good. That's kind of the whole point of expiration.

roksmith 04-12-2012 07:57 AM

No proclamation has an expiration date. But most individual contest proclamations list the name and date of an event. If that date includes a year, then the proclamation is good for only that year according to the AR. That is contradictory to previous KCBS guidance. According to the Royal, this has always been the case from their perspective, but they have relied on KCBS to make sure the contests were up to date.
Doc, I don't think the organizers are to blame here for two reasons.
1. When we are given a sample proclamation to follow and the sample has a date with a year on it..and we're told it's fine, why should we question the sanctioning body?
2. At least in our state, ya don't get to exactly draft the proclamation for the governor. We sent a copy of the sample we were given and it came back with a date with year.

My thoughts would be that once a contest is proclaimed a state championship by the governor, it would from then on be one. I'm fully sure it was intended to be that way.

One thing is for sure....somebody who knew about the decision should be contacting these organizers. Not everybody reads this board.

drbbq 04-12-2012 08:26 AM

I'm not blaming the organizers at all but I also don't think it's fair to blame the Royal.

I suspect some of these procs are pretty old and I don't think a dated one was meant to be good forever. I'm sure it's a hassle to get a new one and I'm sure it would have been a hassle to make everyone get a new one and keep track of them all, but just because it's a hassle doesn't mean you don't have to do it. But in typical KCBS fashion they don't want to make anyone mad so they just let it bleed. Now the Royal decides to fix it and they look like the bad guys.

IMO the bottom line is that the State Championship thing is antiquated and corrupted and needs a complete overhaul.

Diva 04-12-2012 09:28 AM

I was told, when I worked at KCBS, that when the contest organizer got their proclamation it was good for as many years as they consecutively had their contest. If the contest was to "skip" a year, they would have to get a new one, other than that, it was good to go.

I know that Tracy knew that when she ran the Royal, because we had a conversation about it. That was several years ago, whether she passed that tidbit of information on, I don't know. Whether the Executive Director cared to share it with Jolene and Melissa, I don't know.

Jorge 04-12-2012 09:45 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by roksmith (Post 2012561)
No proclamation has an expiration date. But most individual contest proclamations list the name and date of an event. If that date includes a year, then the proclamation is good for only that year according to the AR. That is contradictory to previous KCBS guidance. According to the Royal, this has always been the case from their perspective, but they have relied on KCBS to make sure the contests were up to date.
Doc, I don't think the organizers are to blame here for two reasons.
1. When we are given a sample proclamation to follow and the sample has a date with a year on it..and we're told it's fine, why should we question the sanctioning body?
2. At least in our state, ya don't get to exactly draft the proclamation for the governor. We sent a copy of the sample we were given and it came back with a date with year.

My thoughts would be that once a contest is proclaimed a state championship by the governor, it would from then on be one. I'm fully sure it was intended to be that way.

One thing is for sure....somebody who knew about the decision should be contacting these organizers. Not everybody reads this board.

Speaking solely for myself, and not representing KCBS or the board....

Just because you've heard nothing to date, doesn't mean that nothing is being done. If you have specific concerns feel free to email me at gmullins@kcbs.us. I'll provide my cell # at that point if you'd like to discuss it personally.

Dustaway 04-12-2012 10:45 AM

Ray, I agree with you regarding the damn state proclamation it is out of date and it's a monkey see monkey do type of thing we have contest in Texas that have well over 50 teams competing each year and just because they have seen other contest with "state proclamation" then they fill the need to run out and get one so they can claim its a state championship.

they way the AR looks at who qualifies for the Invitational really needs to be looked at and discussed further

Slamdunkpro 04-12-2012 03:38 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by drbbq (Post 2012599)
I'm not blaming the organizers at all but I also don't think it's fair to blame the Royal.

........

IMO the bottom line is that the State Championship thing is antiquated and corrupted and needs a complete overhaul.

From conversations I've had recently I'm not sure that it's fair to put this wholly on KCBS either. Yes KCBS dropping the tracking was the catalyst but from what I've pieced together there was never anything written anywhere about how this whole procedure worked. It was all verbally passed down from one person to another based on that person's interpretation thus becoming diluted & corrupted over time. What the AR is doing right now does amount to a complete overhaul and I hope we'll see written concrete requirements at the end.

Vince RnQ 04-12-2012 04:00 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Smoke Ring (Post 2011870)
KCBS used to track proclamations and send AR and Jack organizers a report listing all the qualifying contests and the GCs.
.
.
.
.
KCBS no longer serves its members.

Garry, I certainly respect your opinion but I think that as it pertains to tracking of proclamations and Grand Championships, I think your closing comment is awfully broad. Here's why...

Not every Head Cook that has ever won a KCBS sanctioned contest is also a KCBS Member. Many of us are but not all of us. Should KCBS "serve its members" by only reporting the GCs of paying members? That would certainly be a fair and reasonable thing to do and I wouldn't mind if KCBS took that position and marketed it as a Members Only benefit. It seems to me that we paying Members have been subsidizing this "benefit" for a lot of Non-Members over the years.

Look, I know this is splitting hairs but at what point does KCBS decide to take care of those of us who do pay dues and let those who do not fend for themselves? If they are going to report for all GCs, why not include all teams in the ToY race? Same logic if you ask me. Being in ToY is a benefit of Membership.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 08:50 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2014, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.
vBulletin Optimisation provided by vB Optimise v2.6.0 Beta 4 (Lite) - vBulletin Mods & Addons Copyright © 2014 DragonByte Technologies Ltd.
2003 -2012 BBQ-Brethren Inc. All rights reserved. All Content and Flaming Pig Logo are registered and protected under U.S and International Copyright and Trademarks. Content Within this Website Is Property of BBQ Brethren Inc. Reproduction or alteration is strictly prohibited.