View Full Version : Brisket & Pork Butt

04-09-2014, 01:07 PM
Hi All Just recieved my order of,Simply Marvelous,Cherry-Spicy Apple- Sweet Seduction and Blue Hogs Original Sauce.
What would be best rub to use on Pork Butts and Brisket?
Thanks Dan

04-10-2014, 09:14 AM
My answer would be yes...

big brother smoke
04-10-2014, 09:32 AM
Yes, Yes. Or D all of above:-D

04-10-2014, 12:12 PM
Hi Soooo it doesn't matter which of the 3 rubs on use on Brisket:confused:
I know they will do GOOD on ribs.:-D
Just got my order for SM Cherry-Spicy Apple-Sweet Seduction on this Monday,4-7-14. They still had the old labels on jars.?? Hope they hold well.

Thanks DanB

04-10-2014, 11:17 PM
SanB, i love any and all Simply Marvelous products and used them in competition when i could compete and they are all my family and i use even now. Any of them work well on pork butts, especially if you add a little Season-all. The three rubs you mentioned work really well in combination, too. You could layer all three on one butt...that will taste great.,.however, if youve never tried them, i would try one at a time, starting with Spicy Apple and then cook teo more butts - each with one of the others...and thena fouth, with them all. Dang, i must be hungry. LOL. The main thing is not to sweat it, whichever route you go, your pork will be Simply Marvelous.

I homestly habe never used any of those on brisket. I use Simply Marvelous Peppererd Cow. If i dont have that, i use Simply Marvelous Sweet & Spicy. I use S.M. Season-all on every brisket, as a second layer. HOWEVER, i, personally, think any of the ones you have will work well.

Enjoy nd please let us know how the butt and brisket turn out. Post pics if ya can.

04-11-2014, 08:50 AM
Hi First I'm going to start with ribs, use Cherry on one rack and Spicy Apple on the other, maybe along with Sweet Seduction.
Thanks DanB

04-13-2014, 05:09 PM
Hi All Just rubbed my 3.5 lb Butt with Simply Marvelous, Cherry rub, wrapped in plastic and back into the fridge until tomorrow morning.
Then I will hit it with some Montreal Seasonings/salt an pepper.
I also have a rack of Spares and Baby Backs. I'm going to rub with one SM Spicy Apple, the other Cherry.
Thanks Dan

04-14-2014, 05:45 PM
Hi All The results are in. The winner is the Cherry and Sweet Seduction rub.
Spicy Apple was a little too spicy for my wife, anyway to tame it down some?
The Butt is still cooking.
Pic in the mext post "IF" they load?
Thanks DanB

04-14-2014, 06:01 PM
Rib Pics
1st pic rubbed and ready to go.
Top rack Baby Backs, with Cherry N Sweet Seduction
Bottom rack St Louis with Spicy Apple

2nd pic smoked 3hrs...foiled 2hrs..1/2 back on the smoker.

04-15-2014, 08:08 AM
Hi Here is a pic of the butt. Came out nice n juicy and tasted great!!!

big brother smoke
04-16-2014, 12:21 AM
Hi Dan,

Sorry for the the late chime in, I was out to sea for a few days with no interweb connection. Your butt looks juicy indeed! :-D