PDA

View Full Version : chicken wings in a comp?


davefan360
06-13-2013, 08:52 PM
I don't like thighs, I can cook them but I just don't like them. I know I can do wings but has anyone done them with ok results? Just an idea.

jasonjax
06-13-2013, 09:11 PM
I asked this once before and the vast majority said they didn't know anyone who consistently did well with chicken wings.

I LOVE my wings versus thighs or breasts also, but I guess they just don't stand up in comps for whatever reason.

I'm just an amateur competitor so maybe some of the more seasoned folks will chime in also though.

davefan360
06-13-2013, 09:21 PM
my view on it is, if the judges are getting thighs from 90% of the teams some wings might be a nice change. but what do I know. maybe I will have to try it one time and see where we stand when the dust clears.

EMTTLC
06-13-2013, 09:28 PM
I've cooked wings at a number of comps with the intention of turning them in. Each time I back out for one reason or an other and go with the old stand by- thighs. I'm just kinda chicken, pardon the pun. I've judged 14 KCBS comps and only seen a handful of wings turned in, none of them were very good. I still believe that a good wing has just as good a chance as anything else. This weekend, it's thighs alone, but next weekend I'm thinking of giving the wings a shot again

CivilWarBBQ
06-13-2013, 09:33 PM
I'm doing wings all season this year. I've only done two contests so far. They finished 11th out of 33 in the first event, 45th out of 47 the second. I don't count the poor finish though because bad weather screwed up my timing and I had a terrible cook on all meats.

I have four more events on the schedule in the fall, so we'll see.

Rub
06-13-2013, 09:42 PM
As a group, judges prefer thighs over wings. You will take a hit on your score with just wings the majority of the time in my experiences.

Ron_L
06-13-2013, 09:44 PM
I don't like thighs, I can cook them but I just don't like them. I know I can do wings but has anyone done them with ok results? Just an idea.

First, what you like has nothing to do with competition BBQ :-D

Second, There's no reason why perfectly cooked and seasoned ribs wouldn't do well, but there is much less leeway with wings. Thighs, since they are fattier, have are more forgiving.

davefan360
06-13-2013, 09:44 PM
thanks. I think I am going to cook some and then do a back up just in case. the comp is next weekend so I will let you know what happens.

davefan360
06-13-2013, 09:50 PM
but I thought the judges were only supposed to judge what was in the box, not what they want to see in the box. I know this has going around and around. so I have do what some thighs and wings. and see what I turn in come 12 O'clock,

Ron_L
06-13-2013, 10:00 PM
but I thought the judges were only supposed to judge what was in the box, not what they want to see in the box.

True, but not all judges follow that.

nthole
06-13-2013, 10:02 PM
I can cook AMAZING wings. And never was more than 3 from DAL. Feel free to cook them. Expect to lose though.

Like Ronelle said. It ain't about you, it's about dem judges.

CBQ
06-13-2013, 10:54 PM
but I thought the judges were only supposed to judge what was in the box, not what they want to see in the box. I know this has going around and around. so I have do what some thighs and wings. and see what I turn in come 12 O'clock,

True, but I have gotten wings in the box on the few occasions when I judge instead of cook. I didn't mark it down for being a wing. I DID mark it down for flavor and mouth feel though. The flavor was OK, and I might have liked it better if there was MORE of it, but biting a drumstick just doesn't deliver the goods the way a thigh does. It's just too small to fill your mouth with chicken-y goodness. <<insert comment about my big mouth here>> :becky:

Judges shouldn't hold it against you for putting in a wing, but they will judge the entry as an overall BBQ experience, and in that regard I just think it's hard to deliver that whole experience to the judge with a small piece of meat.

peterz
06-13-2013, 11:49 PM
Myself as a KCBS judge I would love to see some wings in the box. But then
again, its just me.............

Hawg Father of Seoul
06-14-2013, 12:20 AM
True, but I have gotten wings in the box on the few occasions when I judge instead of cook. I didn't mark it down for being a wing. I DID mark it down for flavor and mouth feel though. The flavor was OK, and I might have liked it better if there was MORE of it, but biting a drumstick just doesn't deliver the goods the way a thigh does. It's just too small to fill your mouth with chicken-y goodness. <<insert comment about my big mouth here>> :becky:

Judges shouldn't hold it against you for putting in a wing, but they will judge the entry as an overall BBQ experience, and in that regard I just think it's hard to deliver that whole experience to the judge with a small piece of meat.

This is SO true.

boogiesnap
06-14-2013, 06:28 AM
http://www.bbq-brethren.com/forum/showthread.php?t=104716

the pictures are gone, but here's a pretty informative thread from a bit back regarding.

Sawdustguy
06-14-2013, 09:14 AM
As a group, judges prefer thighs over wings. You will take a hit on your score with just wings the majority of the time in my experiences.

Thats a big problem because the judges are not supposed to let their personal preferences affect their scores.

MikeJ65
06-14-2013, 10:54 AM
Thats a big problem because the judges are not supposed to let their personal preferences affect their scores.

Actually, I don't think that judges have preferences any different than the general population. Thighs are going to land on the judging plate hot and moist and the skin is easy to manipulate for tenderness either by using enough heat or scraping.

Wings are much more likely to either be dry or have tough skin. Put your wings and thighs in a garnished box for 20 minutes and decide which you prefer at that point, taking one or two good bites from each.

Rub
06-14-2013, 11:15 AM
Thats a big problem because the judges are not supposed to let their personal preferences affect their scores.

That sure would be nice wouldn't it? It doesn't take much to knock you out of the running.