PDA

View Full Version : Rate my Brisket Box


"Bone to Bark" BBQ
05-05-2012, 07:44 PM
Tell me what you think...... Thanks in advance!

AZScott
05-05-2012, 07:47 PM
I would say a low 8 average score which is good. I wouldn't be surprised to see 7's, 8's and 9's with that entry..

Big Country BBQ
05-05-2012, 09:18 PM
box looks cramped. I would cut to make more uniform. and add more burnt ends!

BRBBQ
05-05-2012, 09:37 PM
I would say 8, add 6 burnt ends, parsley needs a little work

Twelvegaugepump
05-05-2012, 09:57 PM
I would say 8, add 6 burnt ends, parsley needs a little work

Same here. 8 and work on the greens in the front.

txschutte
05-05-2012, 11:56 PM
Add lettuce base to your box to raise the presentation, trim your briskie to fit the box. Remember to trim so the brisket is round on the ends, and add 2 more slices, and make sure there are 8 burnt ends.

I rate 7.

Captain P.J.
05-06-2012, 12:06 AM
I'd say 7. The burnt ends look dry and the front slice looks like a mess.

accuseal
05-06-2012, 06:19 AM
It does look crowded. Can't really see the burnt ends. Need to show them off a bit more. For me solid 7 maybe 8.

Sent from my SCH-I905 using Tapatalk 2

"Bone to Bark" BBQ
05-06-2012, 07:18 AM
Thank you all for the critiques... and I assume the burnt ends always tend to go in the back of the box, right? I'll try another one in a week or three and we'll see how that one is!

BBQchef33
05-06-2012, 09:15 AM
Id go 7 or 8 too.

not to hijack but we have 2 comments about parsley or greens needing work?

Would sloppy parsley affect your score? Sure hope not.


Sent from my DROIDX using Tapatalk 2

rcorun
05-06-2012, 09:15 AM
7 going by the pic. maybe 8 at the table

Lake Dogs
05-06-2012, 09:18 AM
7 or 8

CBQ
05-06-2012, 10:12 AM
not to hijack but we have 2 comments about parsley or greens needing work?

I hope the mods punish that thead hijacker :becky:

I do think judges will mark you based on the overall impressions they have of the box. They might not specifically mark down for the garnish, but if it conveys an overall impression of a sloppy box, expect to get dinged for it.

(I have also gotten 2 comment cards saying my meat was too cold, and KCBS says you aren't supposed to judge on that...so I certainly wouldn't rely on the expectation that all six judges will know and strictly follow the rules.)

hamiltont
05-06-2012, 10:36 AM
I would give it a 7 or 8. A little more uniformity with each slice would help. If you're going to put burnt ends in the box be sure to have enough for all the judges. Personally I like to see an equal number of slices & burnt ends my self. And, yes, whether the box has any greens or not should not effect the judges appearance score. No one has mentioned the "smoke ring" yet. That shouldn't be considered in the appearance score either. Cheers!!!

Slamdunkpro
05-06-2012, 11:24 AM
6, maybe a 7 in person. The front slice is so ragged on the left side I can't get away from it. The point chunks in the back look just tossed in. The saucing is uneven and there are bits and flecks of matter on the slicers (or my monitor is really dirty). Meat is sunk down into the garnish, almost hidden.

Non factors for me but,,,,,

The greens - judges don't like to see stems and there are quite a few visible in the box. Unenlightened judges will ding you for that.

The smoke ring. It's so large that the meat almost looks cured.

ique
05-06-2012, 01:30 PM
The smoke ring. It's so large that the meat almost looks cured.

Yes at best 7 for me, mostly because it looks more like pastrami then BBQ.

MattCom
05-06-2012, 03:26 PM
I'm not a judge, so I won't throw out a number. What I would do is get that black booger off that first slice. Only 5 burnt ends, you need to have at least 1 per judge, or by my rule at least one extra. So the last judge still has a choice.

Pigs on Fire
05-06-2012, 04:20 PM
not to hijack but we have 2 comments about parsley or greens needing work?

Would sloppy parsley affect your score? Sure hope not.

It would be nice to see all the CBJ's, table captains and master judges chime in on this.

We all know the answer, tho.

The Virginian
05-06-2012, 04:32 PM
More meat, less greens. Too much shine (moist is one thing, but I think its a little over the top with droplets on the meat). Plus all the stuff that Slamdunkpro said.

G$
05-06-2012, 05:11 PM
Yes at best 7 for me, mostly because it looks more like pastrami then BBQ.

So that was going to be my question. We hear over and over not to judge a smoke ring. Well, that one looks 'weird' and I can't help "judging" it because it effects how much I want to sample the brisket.

From here, it looks like those slices are extremely on a bias. The bark looks almost burnt. The front slice is ragged. The left of the slices look mostly complete, the right look mostly trimmed.

I am willing to change my vote in person, but with what I have to work with ... 7

DISCLAIMER: I am NOT a judge.

"Bone to Bark" BBQ
05-06-2012, 06:53 PM
Yes at best 7 for me, mostly because it looks more like pastrami then BBQ.
Yeah, I don't know whats up with the smoke ring being so pronounced...... the only thing different I did with this brisket than any others, is that I injected it.??? And for smoke, I only used a couple little chunks of wood? Crazy..... Oh well, it all tasted good.

JimmyDAL
05-07-2012, 05:29 AM
Hamilton, to me the smoke ring looks like TQ. JMHO

hamiltont
05-07-2012, 09:01 AM
Hamilton, to me the smoke ring looks like TQ. JMHO
Could very well be, or at least from some source of nitrate.

Uncle Buds BBQ
05-07-2012, 09:26 AM
When I look at a box I ask myself one question "Do I want to jump in and eat the whole thing?".....the answer is YES.

I give it a 9.

Stoke&Smoke
05-07-2012, 12:22 PM
I hope the mods punish that thead hijacker :becky:

I do think judges will mark you based on the overall impressions they have of the box. They might not specifically mark down for the garnish, but if it conveys an overall impression of a sloppy box, expect to get dinged for it.

(I have also gotten 2 comment cards saying my meat was too cold, and KCBS says you aren't supposed to judge on that...so I certainly wouldn't rely on the expectation that all six judges will know and strictly follow the rules.)

I think judges will downgrade if the garnish detracts from the meat. I don't think teams would spend so much time perfecting "putting greens" if they didn't think it was important.

Been a while since I judged, but if a judge submits a comment card about something that shouldn't be considered (like the temp of the meat) shouldn't that be brought to the attention of the table captain/rep?

As others have said, there are some spots, crumbs, whatever on a couple slices that should have been removed with tweezers, and if you're going to put burnt ends in the box, you do need at least 5.

Was TQ used on that brisket? Never seen a natural smoke ring that large

NRA4Life
05-07-2012, 12:44 PM
I'd give it a 7 for all the reasons already stated.

"Bone to Bark" BBQ
05-07-2012, 06:19 PM
Hamilton, to me the smoke ring looks like TQ. JMHO

If TQ consists of beef broth, onion powder and some Montreal seasoning...... then I guess thats the problem ! Somebody elaborate on "TQ".... what the heck is it?

Smokin Mike
05-07-2012, 06:39 PM
If TQ consists of beef broth, onion powder and some Montreal seasoning...... then I guess thats the problem ! Somebody elaborate on "TQ".... what the heck is it?


Morton Tender Quick, apply and then rinse off, instant red ring.

Mo-Dave
05-07-2012, 07:33 PM
I think everyone here forgets how little time a judge really gets to look at an entry. I have forgot but I think it is about 4 or 5 sec, maybe as much as 7 or 8 average. That is not much time to pick out anything that is not way obvious. Anyone showing there stuff and asking for comments here should keep that in mind. Guess I would give it a 7 from the pic but in real time could be different.

Having said that, the smoke ring does looked forced but if its a new judge that could be a wow factor for them but you can't know that. I would like to have seen the slices more evenly cut meaning removing the small end so they look more uniform. Yes fill the bottom with extra lettuce to raise the meat up.

I have a pet notion that, putting more than one cut of meat such as burnt ends and slices or pulled meat can go against you as much as help. What if, say the slices are great but the burnt ends or pulled is not, you have probably lowered the score, of course this should only apply to taste and texture and not appearance. So take your pick and just do your best with what you can and don't confuse the judge with 3 or 4 different cuts to make a score with, that second one may be your worst. Do make sure you have at least 6, 7 or 8 slices is better of what ever you put in it.