please rate this box

[RoadHawgBBQ]

http://flic.kr/p/brhzX3

[CivilWarBBQ]

I'd give it an X.

(jk. Image post failed, my friend)

[Lake Dogs]

Zero.

[Bentley]

There is to much red in the meat, I would grade down for that.

[Panthers65]

tough crowd,

Here ya go OP
http://farm7.staticflickr.com/6102/6849716076_da3ff90788_b.jpg

[Bentley]

I would judge it a 7.

[Warthog]

I would give it a 7. The pieces need to be more uniform in size and color.

[CMALANGA]

I'd give it a 7.

[Slamdunkpro]

6 - uniformity & color are a factor but it also looks a little on the dry side.

[bbq.tom]

7
Pieces are too dis-similar and are being swallowed up by the garnish.
Looks like chicken (that's a GOOD thing), but could have been trimmed a bit to make them more the same. Sauce could be more evenly spread too.

[mobow]

7. Trim off those little pieces sticking out.

[Lake Dogs]

7 refer to above

[HOG WILD BBQ]

7.5 imo

[Tack]

gotta give it a 7 also. Now if they all looked like the right hand piece in the center row it would be a different story

[big brother smoke]

7 nice start!

[Red Valley BBQ]

I'd have to give it a 6.

[Bbq Bubba]

I would give it a 7. The pieces need to be more uniform in size and color.

Why?

6 - uniformity & color are a factor but it also looks a little on the dry side.

I looked a lot longer than 10 seconds and dont see dry at all?

Ill give it a 8, mostly because the meat seems buried in the box around some rough looking lettuce.
Color and finish look good.
Do they really have to be 6 farken matching pieces of chicken?

[RoadHawgBBQ]

thanks guys.. need tough critics... that is y i like this site

[CivilWarBBQ]

High 7 with a typical 3 second viewing.

More attention to detail and lowered garnish and you're there. You want the picture to be what strikes people first, not the frame.

[KevinK]

I would give it a strong 7 and if you would make them look a bit more uniform and not hide any pieces under garnish probably would rate a 9. Color is spot on IMO.